Captain Melville

Wednesday, February 6, 2013

Captain Melville – 34 Franklin St, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
Captain’s Burger
Dress Code:
Smart Casual
10 minutes
Would we recommend:

When the owners of Miss Libertine realised they were growing up and the hangovers and drunken nightclub patrons were getting a bit tiresome, they decided to completely renovate the heritage listed, 1853 bluestone building and convert it into a gastro pub. Appointing Shayne McCallum as head chef to oversee the menu, they’ve created traditional Australian pub classics as well as some more adventurous dishes like rabbit pie and tuna tartare. We of course went for the burger with Sher Wagyu beef, bacon, cheese, Yarra Valley egg, a soft brioche-like bun and hand cut chips.

“I was really surprised with this place. After being informed by the waitress that this is “the best burger your going to try”, I have to say I was a little sceptical. When it arrived at the table gleaming with its sweet soft glazed bun, I knew they had put something special together! Two perfectly cooked and seasoned patties separated by some great bacon. Juicy and full of flavour, the crunchy tangy pickles added a nice bite. The oozing egg and melted cheese also gave the burger a nice creamy texture. I’m usually not a massive fan of handcut cuts but these were pretty good.”
“Everyone loves a good surprise, especially when you’re least expecting it. So the moment I saw that it had double patties (not mentioned on the menu), I was extremely elated. The bun was super soft with a nice shiny glaze (best compared to the sweet Chinese Bread Top rolls) and it really helped enhance the perfectly seasoned, juicy beef and creaminess of the cheese and egg. This burger is great, but it’s the extra details like the crispy slices of tangy pickle and the spice from some ground pepper that really made this burger stand out.”
“These double Wagyu patties were delicious! The cheese oozing out of the burger, combined with the fresh egg really got my juices going. The bacon in between the two patties was a good move as it broke-up each bite with its salty goodness. I really liked the super soft bun with its sweet glaze. The hand cut chips were great! Fluffy on the inside and nicely cooked on the out!”
“Walking up to the old Miss Libertine, I really wasnt expecting a whole lot. Walking in however, changed that for me. I suddenly forgot about all the late night discos I’d attended. I was standing in a place that looks like it had a bunch of money poured into it. Fancy as hell, almost like a Newmarket or Halfmoon kind of joint. However, I am suspicious of most burgers that use Wagyu beef these days. Purely because some places claim they use the expensive stuff just so they can lighten your wallet. But as soon as it landed in front of me I forgot all about my suspicions and went straight into Playboy photographer mode. This burger made good use of the “Three S’s”: soft, salty and sexy. The double patties with bacon sandwiched in between were genius! Every other bite I received an express delivery of beautiful charr. The egg was good but I really dont think it needed it. With the double cheese it was more than enough creaminess. I mean, it did end up falling apart. But I didnt care. I just wanted this burger to keep going and going. Stellar start to 2013!”
Captain Melville on Urbanspoon


One of Favorite Burgers in the CDB for sure. Nice work Lads!

Kevin Karlberg ( February 6, 2013 at 17:31 )

Tried this out the other night… not the greatest burger in Melbourne, far too much fat dripping from this baby!

Jess ( March 8, 2013 at 12:50 )

Just tried this one, big fan. So rich and creamy, and one of the best buns I’ve come across.

Daryl ( March 15, 2013 at 14:27 )

Tried it. Pretty good but the skinny patties needed more char… it lacked smokiness.
needed some relish for flavour as the ol tomato sauce just didn’t cut it… most perfectly cooked egg on a burger ever but

good effort but not the best in town and at that price $21 it needs to be something really special

Ray ( April 19, 2013 at 14:16 )

Please Leave a Reply

Like Us!
Stay Connected
From the menu, which one we ordered.
How sloppy and juicy the burger is.
Dress Code:
What's the venue like?
For how long were we drowsy after the burger.
Would We Recommend: