South Melbourne Trader

Monday, March 31, 2014

South Melbourne Trader – 111 Cecil St,
South Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
Wagyu burger
Dress Code:
Smart Casual
20 minutes
Would we recommend:
If you’re in the area

The South Melbourne Trader is one of those contemporary pub venues that’s built to cater for all sorts of crowds, from the big lunch time work crowds on a Friday, to the modern family who’s not in the particular mood to cook. Located only 2 minutes’ walk from the South Melbourne Markets this place has done well to build a local following in an area with plenty of old time pubs on offer. Former Rockpool Bar & Grill chef Johnon MacDonald has brought his knowledge to SMT and put together a quality Wagyu burger at an affordable price. It arrived on a brioche bun with a Wagyu pattie, house made pickles, lettuce, tomato, mayo, Jamaican Jerk and hand cut chips.

“At first bite, several of the distinct flavours made be double guess whether or not I’d actually eaten this burger before. Once I lifted up the top bun and the bright pink pickled onions stared back at me, revealing the uncanny similarities between this and the Wagyu burger at Rockpool. The brioche bun combined with all the pickled vegetables and Jamaican Jerk sauce unfortunately overpowered the beef patty, which was cooked a little longer than ideal. However, when tasted on its own had great flavour.”
“The burger had a very tasty pattie with the right level of moisture in it and at the perfect thickness. The bun did get a bit mushy towards the end, but it made the distance, so no real complaints. There was minimal green stuff on offer, but they were very generous on the mayo. For a lunch time option I think it’s slightly on the heavy side, but that’s what long Friday lunches are for. Chips were average.”
“I’m normally the kind of guy to put more mayo on top of mayo. But this experience was even too creamy for me. The Rockpool on a budget burger still had really good moments. It makes sense for them to copy its greatness as not every one has had the pleasure of visiting Neil Perry’s fine establishment. The beef was by far the standout with a nice beefy charr to it, but it needed to be heroed more. All the sauces and onions stole its limelight. It looked small, but the sleepiness that hung around afterwards was enough to make me think about pulling over on my drive home. Pretty good but I’d go the original (and pay for it) any day of the week.”
The South Melbourne Trader on Urbanspoon


Please note:

The chef (myself) who created this burger left the SMT almost a year ago, I cannot comment on your personal experience of my creation, I apologies if it was not as intended.

Johnon Macdonald ( November 25, 2014 at 23:41 )

This place unfortunately has been living off this review ever since. I wondered why it did not meet expectation when we tried and now find out that the chef left quite some time ago would explain. Very average now.

Louise ( January 29, 2015 at 09:33 )

Please Leave a Reply

Like Us!
Stay Connected
From the menu, which one we ordered.
How sloppy and juicy the burger is.
Dress Code:
What's the venue like?
For how long were we drowsy after the burger.
Would We Recommend: